We rented our villa out via Select for a number of years - they are totally legitimate and I'm not aware of any problems that guests had with their properties - we certainly didn't ever get negative feedback and someone always seemed to be available whenever there was a maintenance issue which needed attention..The lady who runs the company has been working in the holiday rentals market for many years (she previously worked for Prestige). Because they are a relatively small local company they possibly don't appear as slick as other companies which have more staff, shiny new offices and operate on a much larger scale - on the other hand, the service you get is perhaps more personalised. We eventually moved elsewhere to a company that gave us a guaranteed rental income (Select simply paid a percentage of the weeks actually sold). I do take your point about the website - we moved from them just prior to the explosion in online booking so it was never really a problem for us. However, as I said it's a while since we had any contact with them. Maybe look on one of the Trip Advisor forums to see if anyone has a more recent experience?